On the first forecast call of 2027, ask the rep who picked January 31. If it was the buyer, there’s a conversation to have about what happens between now and signature. If it was the rep, it’s worth finding out how December 31 got into the forecast in the first place.

Consider two $100,000 deals that missed December. In one, the procurement director returned a marked-up contract and booked January 12 to settle the remaining terms. In the other, the rep’s last email went unanswered. The rep chose January 31 because the CRM needed a new close date. Between them, those deals put $200,000 on the Q1 pipeline report. So far, the buyers have committed to one meeting.

Sales leaders have good reason to press for that distinction. For its September 2026 U.S. Revenue Benchmark Report, Salesloft worked with Censuswide to survey 500 sales and revenue decision-makers at U.S. companies with at least 200 employees. Respondents estimated that stalls, slipped close dates and other execution problems affected 19.7% of pipeline. Only about 32% said they could tell immediately why a deal had stalled. The first figure measures how widespread several problems are. It offers little help in deciding which of the two contracts finance can count on.

What the buyer put on the calendar

The procurement director has done the first rep a favor. The markup identifies the terms still in dispute, and the meeting gives both sides a date to resolve them. Now the manager can ask what happens if both sides settle those terms on January 12. Whose desk does the contract go to next?

The answer could move the forecast either way. A finance director holding approved funds for a February rollout gives the rep a reason to defend a Q1 close. A department head who needs to resubmit the purchase in the new budget year has another decision ahead of them. Both buyers might show up on January 12 with every intention of agreeing on contract language.

That change of hands is easy to miss when the account team has spent months with one enthusiastic sponsor. In a memoryBlue discussion of sales qualification, Revenue Arc’s Mark Ward and memoryBlue’s Glenn Haertel examined how people involved in the same purchase can have different priorities. A department head can explain why the team needs the software. Procurement can explain what it takes to buy it. The rep needs both accounts to put a credible date on the deal.

Where the second $100,000 belongs

Keep the quiet account open and take it out of the Q1 commitment. Silence alone tells the manager very little about whether the company will eventually buy. It tells finance even less about whether the company will sign by March 31. Give the rep a date to follow up, and record it as the rep’s task. Calling it the buyer’s close date is how the deal got here.

For every December carryover, the forecast notes should say why the buyer delayed, who owns the outstanding decision and when that person agreed to act. Where the buyer hasn’t answered, leave the question open. An accurate gap in the record gives the next account call a purpose.

When finance asks about the $200,000, the manager can be precise. One contract is in negotiation, with a January 12 review and signature timing to confirm. The other is awaiting a reply. Put the first back on the forecast agenda after procurement meets. Put the second on the rep’s call list.